Supreme Court Rules Muscogee Reservation Endures for Federal Criminal Law

The Equal Justice Under Law inscription on the Supreme Court building

The Supreme Court ruled Thursday that Congress never dissolved the Muscogee (Creek) reservation in eastern Oklahoma. The 5–4 decision addresses whether land within the reservation remains Indian country under the federal Major Crimes Act.

The case arose from Jimcy McGirt’s challenge to Oklahoma’s authority to prosecute him. The Court’s majority concluded that the state lacked jurisdiction over the crimes at issue because of where they occurred and McGirt’s status as a citizen of a federally recognized tribe.

The opinion returns to a promise made in federal law and asks who had the power to undo it. Its immediate effect is on criminal jurisdiction. Authorities will now have to determine how to handle cases affected by the decision.

Reporting source. Cover photograph: Bachrach44. Image reuse terms.